Artisan Holiday Cookie Preorders 2025

What sets these cookies apart is the character and intention behind every flavor...

Each one has its own texture, its own depth, its own moment — from soft-chewy warmth to crisp-tender edges, from bright citrus notes to rich, slow-building spice. Even if you’ve tasted cookies in these categories before, these are different in the best way: more layered, more balanced, and still comfortingly familiar. Together, they create a holiday lineup that feels thoughtful, memorable, and genuinely delicious.

How to order:

All holiday cookie boxes are organized by pickup day. Simply choose the date that works for you, and you’ll find the full lineup of cookie boxes available on that page. The offerings are the same for every pickup day, though order capacity limits vary by day.

For information on pickup windows and packaging, please see below.

Skip to results list
Availability
Price
to
The highest price is $42.00
Clear
4 items

Filter

Availability
Price
to
The highest price is $42.00

Pickup Windows:

Wed Dec 10 & Wed Dec 17: Two pickup windows are available — 10am–12pm (AM) or 6pm–8pm (PM).

Please specify AM or PM in the Order Notes section in your cart before you check out.

Sun Dec 14 & Sun Dec 21: One pickup window — 10am–2pm.

No need to specify a window for these dates.

Pickup Location:

Pickup location is in Ballard/Loyal Heights 98117.

Details will be provided at checkout.

About the packaging:

The bakery boxes haven’t arrived yet, which is why photos of the finished boxed cookies aren’t shown. Each order will be packed in a sturdy chipboard bakery box, tied with ribbon, and finished with a Curiosity Created Goods brand label. A paper insert with ingredients and cookie descriptions will also be included. As soon as the packaging is delivered, the site will be updated with full photos.